Skip to Content

Our Highest Rated Costco Wines of 2016

Our Highest Rated Costco Wines of 2016

As I do every year, I want to present a list of the wines we bought at Costco and rated the highest throughout 2016.

It’s always a little tricky because many of these wines will be long gone from your local warehouse, but you never know what you’ll find if you’re on the lookout.  Sometimes wines reappear at Costco as fast as they disappear.  It’s all part of the Costco hunt that we love (and hate) so much.

I also want to thank all of you for reading and supporting this site.  We started this blog on a whim in June of 2009, never knowing what might become of it.  But we found a large group of like minded, passionate wine buyers who love finding and exploring the wines (and great values) offered at Costco.

We now have over 9,000 email subscribers and many more who follow us on Twitter and Facebook.  It’ s quite remarkable, and it’s been a lot of fun, so I hope we can keep it going.

Now, let’s look back at the wines we gave our highest ratings to this year (in no particular order).

2013 Las Vertientes Benchmark Reserva Red

2013 Las Vertientes Benchmark Reserva Red

Excellent Mendoza red blend that was discounted $6 to $17.89; 91 points; hard to find

2010 Kirkland Signature Series Brunello di Montalcino

2010 Kirkland Signature Series Brunello di Montalcino

This refers to the 2010 vintage that came out earlier this year that I went 92-93 pts on.  The 2011, not so much.  Dig through your bins and see if you’re lucky enough to find this one.

2004 La Rioja Alta Gran Reserva 9042004 La Rioja Alta Gran Reserva 904

I could rave forever about this wine (and the 2005 that is also out right now).  If you like old world reds with a little age on them, this one is for you, and only $40; 93 points

2013 Four Graces Willamette Valley Pinot Noir

2013 Four Graces Willamette Valley Pinot Noir

Dark, rich Willamette Pinot, memorable finish, great wine for $23; 91 points

2009 Marques de Murrieta Finca Ygay Reserva Rioja

2009 Marques de Murrieta Finca Ygay Reserva Rioja

At $19, this might be one of the biggest values I encountered this year.  Excellent Rioja, drinking perfectly right now; 92 points

2012 Bodega Cuarto Dominio Chento Malbec

2012 Bodega Cuarto Dominio Chento Malbec

Forget what I just said, this might be the biggest value at only $13.89 (actually they’re both pretty awesome wines).  This wine disappeared from my stores but keep an eye out.  92-93 points

2007 Bodega Los Aljibes Selectus

2007 Bodega Los Aljibes Selectus

Another mega bargain at $12.99; Parker rated 94; great Spanish blend with elegance; 92 points for me here

BONUS PICK: Here’s one of my favorite wines I enjoyed this year that Costco is now stocking at a pretty solid price – the 2012 Joseph Phelps Insignia.  For a special occasion you can’t go wrong here, although it’s really young, almost a sin to drink right now.  I’d suggest buying one (or more if you can) to lay down for a few years.  In 10+ years, this wine will be a lot of fun to come back to.

phelps

If you liked this story, please subscribe to our email list and we’ll send you two new Costco wine reviews every week.  And guaranteed, no spam or sharing ever.

Gonzalo Crujeiras

Sunday 8th of January 2017

iT IS VERY HARD TO FIND SPANISH WINES AT Costco, DC and Delaware. Usually there are 2-3 and simply don't last. As one of the worlds biggest producers of lost cost quality wines, there aren't too many Riojas to select. Marques de Murrieta and Cune are excellent but after they sold out, they were not replaced at Costco.

David J. Grycowski

Friday 16th of December 2016

Looking for a excellent "Ice Wine" for New Years to enhance desserts. Any Costco suggestions that would be carried at the New Berlin, WI Store?

srh

Sunday 11th of December 2016

No biggie [I agree with YOUR 92 for the Los Aljibes], but I believe good ol' Mr. Parker rated it 94, not 96. ;)

HAPPY Holidays to you & yours, & **THANK** you for ALL the tips you provide!

Editor

Monday 12th of December 2016

You're right. I'll make the change. Thanks for letting me know.

Charlie Alter

Saturday 10th of December 2016

Enjoy the wine blog but unfortunately none of them ever appear in our local Costco stores in Ohio. Anything I can do with store management to get some of these delivered here?

Editor

Saturday 10th of December 2016

Hi Charlie, sorry to hear you aren't seeing the wines near you. I'm not sure what can make that change (we are independent of Costco) but you can ask your store manager. Hopefully some of our reviewed wines will pop up near you. The Kirkland ones I imagine should make it there at least.

Joanna Rutter

Saturday 10th of December 2016

Can't drink red wine, unfortunately....How about some good whites?

Editor

Saturday 10th of December 2016

Hi Joanna, if you scroll through our ongoing list of recent wine picks (http://costcowineblog.com/tag/top-pick/) there are some whites (Chards, Sancerre, Sauv Blancs) that we enjoyed.

Comments are closed.